How good is it for health to eat eggs?
The egg ... is it good or bad for your health? |
If there was something that defined a perfect meal, the eggs would be on the list of candidates.
They are easy to get, simple to cook, affordable and full of
protein.
"The egg has all the right ingredients to grow an organism, so it is obviously very rich in nutrients," says Christopher
Blesso, Professor of Nutrition Sciences at the University of Connecticut in the United States.
Eating eggs along with other foods can also help our bodies
absorb more vitamins.
- Is it dangerous to eat eggs every day?
For example, one study says that adding an egg to the salad
can increase the amount of vitamin E we get from that dish.
But the convenience or not of eating eggs has been a controversial issue for decades since they have a high cholesterol content,
which several studies have linked to an increased risk of heart disease.
Egg yolk contains about 185 milligrams of cholesterol,
which is more than half of the daily amount of cholesterol (300 mg) that the US
dietary guidelines recommended until recently.
Does that mean that eggs, instead of being an ideal food,
could actually be hurting us?
The cholesterol dilemma
Cholesterol is present in animal products such as red meat and eggs. |
Cholesterol, a yellowish fat produced in our liver and intestines, can be found in each of the cells of our body.
Normally we consider it "bad."
But cholesterol is a fundamental component in our cell
membranes. It is also necessary for the body to produce vitamin D and the
hormones testosterone and estrogen.
We produce all the cholesterol we need, but it is also found
in the animal products we consume, including beef, shrimp and eggs, as well as
cheese and butter.
Cholesterol is transported around our body by lipoprotein
molecules in the blood.
- How many eggs is healthy to eat a week? This new study challenges what we believed
Each person has a different combination of several types of
lipoproteins and our individual composition plays a role in determining our
risk of developing heart disease.
Low-density lipoprotein (LDL) cholesterol, called
"bad" cholesterol, is transported from the liver to arteries and body
tissues.
The researchers say this can cause a buildup of cholesterol
in the blood vessels and increase the risk of cardiovascular disease.
Some fried foods, which contain trans fat, can increase our levels of LDL (or "bad") cholesterol |
Therefore,
the United Kingdom Health Authority (NHS) recalls that high blood cholesterol
content increases the risk of coronary heart disease.
But it
emphasizes that the amount of saturated fat we eat has more effect on the level
of blood cholesterol than the cholesterol from eggs.
Foods
that contain trans fats, in particular, increase our LDL levels.
Although
some trans fats occur naturally in animal products, most are made artificially
and are found in the highest levels in margarines, snacks and some fried and
baked foods, such as cakes and donuts.
- Why we love some foods and hate others (and how to change our tastes)
The regulatory body
"If
your family doctor or healthcare professional told you to watch your
cholesterol level, your priority should be to eliminate saturated fats from
your diet" reads the NHS page.
"If
you maintain a balanced diet, you should only remove the eggs from it if the doctor told you so."
Together
with shrimp, eggs are the only food high in cholesterol and low in saturated
fat.
"While
the cholesterol in eggs is much higher than in meat and other animal products,
saturated fats raise blood cholesterol. This was
proven
by many studies for years, "says María Luz Fernández, Professor of
Nutritional Sciences at the University of Connecticut, in the USA.
His latest research found no relationship between eating eggs and an increased risk of cardiovascular disease.
Cholesterol is harmful when oxidized, but the antioxidants in eggs prevent that process from happening. |
The
discussion about the effects of eggs on health has changed in part because our
bodies can compensate for the cholesterol we consume.
In a
review of 40 2015 studies, researchers at Tufts University in Boston, USA,
could not find any conclusive evidence about the relationship between dietary
cholesterol and heart disease.
"Humans
have good regulation when they consume cholesterol in the diet and will produce
less cholesterol by themselves," says Elizabeth Johnson, a professor of
Nutritional Science research at that university.
- The food that can improve and extend your life: are you eating enough?
Cholesterol benefits
And when
it comes to eggs, cholesterol can pose an even lower risk to health.
Cholesterol
is more harmful when it oxidizes in our arteries, but it is not something that
happens to cholesterol from eggs, says Blesso.
"When
cholesterol is oxidized, it can be inflammatory, and there are all kinds of
antioxidants in eggs that protect it from oxidation," he says.
Also,
some cholesterol may be good for us.
High
density lipoprotein cholesterol (HDL) travels to the liver, where it breaks
down and is eliminated from the body.
Cholesterol is harmful when oxidized, but the antioxidants in eggs prevent that process from happening. |
It is
believed that HDL has a protective effect against cardiovascular disease by
preventing cholesterol from accumulating in the blood.
"People should worry about the cholesterol that circulates in the blood, which is what leads to heart disease," says Fernandez.
What
matters are the proportion of HDL and LDL in our bodies, since high HDL
counteracts the effects of LDL.
However,
although most of us are able to cushion the cholesterol we consume with the
cholesterol that breaks down in our livers, Blesso says that about a third of
people will experience an increase in blood cholesterol from 10% to 15 % after
consuming it.
- The egg that broke the "like" record on Instagram and turned out to be a mental health campaign
Clinical
trials revealed that thin and healthy people are more likely to see an increase
in LDL after eating eggs.
And
those who are overweight, obese or diabetes may see a smaller increase in LDL
and more HDL molecules say Blesso.
So, if
you are a healthy person, eggs could have a more negative effect than if you
are overweight.
But also
if you are healthy, you are more likely to have good levels of HDL, so an
increase in LDL would not be very harmful.
Contradictions
... but other studies found that eggs are associated with a lower risk of heart disease. |
Research
published earlier this year challenges the recent consensus that eggs do not
represent any harm to our health.
After
observing data from 30,000 adults for an average of 17 years, the researchers
discovered that each additional half egg per day consumed there was a
significant relationship with an increased risk of heart disease and death.
- How many eggs are healthy to eat a week? This new study challenges what we believed
The
study monitored patients' diet patterns, general health, and physical activity
to try to isolate the effects of eggs.
"We
found that, for every 300 mg of additional cholesterol a person consumed,
regardless of the food, they came from, they had a 17% higher risk of
cardiovascular disease and an 18% higher risk of mortality from all
causes," says Norrina Allen, one of the study authors who is a professor
of Preventive Medicine at Northwestern University in Illinois, USA
- The hens that lay eggs with medicines used to fight cancer
"We
also found that every half egg per day there was a 6% higher risk of heart
disease and an 8% higher risk of mortality."
Although
the study is one of the largest of its kind to address this specific
relationship between eggs and heart disease, it was an observational work,
without giving an indication of cause and effect.
It was
based on a single set of data that patients gave: participants were asked what
they ate during the previous month or year, and then monitored their health
outcomes for up to 31 years.
There are numerous contradictions in how eggs affect health. |
This
means that the researchers only obtained a still picture of what the
participants were eating, even though diets may change over time.
And the study contradicts past results from other research that suggests that eggs are
good for heart health.
A
previous analysis of half a million adults in China, published in 2018, found
the exact opposite: egg consumption was associated with a lower risk of heart
disease.
- Could you survive by eating only one type of food?
Those
who ate eggs every day had an 18% lower risk of death from heart disease and a
28% lower risk of death from stroke compared to those who did not eat eggs.
Like the previous study, this was also observational, which means that it is impossible
to decipher cause and effect. (Are adults in China healthier because they eat
more eggs, or do eggs make them healthier?)
Egg Benefits
Choline, found in eggs, can protect us from Alzheimer's disease. |
While these studies revived the debate about the impact of cholesterol on eggs in our health, we know that eggs can affect us for other reasons.
Eggs
have a compound called choline that can help protect us against Alzheimer's
disease. It also protects the liver.
Although
it can also have negative effects.
Choline
is metabolized by flora (intestinal microbiota) in a molecule called TMO, which
is then absorbed into the liver and converted to TMAO, a molecule associated
with an increased risk of cardiovascular disease.
- The risk of stopping dairy products before the age of 25
Professor
Blesso wondered if eating a lot of egg hill could lead to elevations of TMAO
and found studies in which it was observed that people had elevated levels of
TMAO up to 12 hours after eating eggs.
Research
that measures the consumption of eggs and TMAO so far has only found transient
increases in TMAO. However, TMAO is measured as a marker of heart disease only
at the basic level, which can be detected when people are fasting.
Blesso
compares this with the way our blood sugar levels temporarily increase after
eating carbohydrates, but high blood sugar levels are only associated with
diabetes when these levels are continuous.
Egg yolks are an excellent source of lutein, which is related to vision benefits |
This may
be because when we eat eggs, we could only get the beneficial effects of
choline, he says.
"The
problem is when, instead of being absorbed by the blood, the hill continues to
the large intestine, where it can become TMA and then TMAO," says
Fernández.
"But
in eggs, choline is absorbed and does not go to the large intestine, so it does
not increase the risk of heart disease."
Meanwhile,
scientists begin to understand the other health benefits of eggs.
Egg
yolks are one of the best sources of lutein, a pigment that is related to a
better view and a lower risk of eye diseases, for example.
"There
are two types of lutein found in the retina of the eye, where you can protect
it from light damage by functioning as a blue light filter," says Johnson.
While
researchers are far from understanding why eggs affect us differently, the vast
majority of recent research suggests that they pose no risk to our health and
are more likely to provide health benefits.
Even so,
eating eggs every day is probably not the healthiest option either.
If the
recommendation is that we have a varied diet, it is better not to put all the
eggs in the same basket.
It is better not to put eggs in the same basket ... |
No comments:
Post a Comment